Historical Background
The small log cabin in the photo served as the county Jail and the gallows can be seen next to it. On November 28, 1872 a soldier and two teamsters were arrested and locked up before they could do harm to Fort Bentonites. Sometime during the evening, it is thought the prisoners set fire to the jail to affect their escape. It didn’t go too well for them as the remains of the soldier and one teamster were found among the ashes. The third man apparently made good on his escape as his body was never found.
The Sheriff's Office was once responsible for a huge portion of Northeastern Montana. The Chouteau County Sheriff's Office has been continuously in operation from the earliest days of settlement of the county. The county is one of the original nine counties that was created on February 2, 1865 and named after Jean and Pierre Chouteau. The area encompasses plains, two mountain ranges, three rivers, and several lesser creeks and streams as well as the majority of the Upper Missouri National Monument, just under 4000 square miles in all. Old records of trials, sentences, and executions were maintained in ledgers and have since been turned over to the Montana Agricultural Museum in Fort Benton. Artifacts from those early years can be found in that museum, as is a portion of the old jail cells brought to Fort Benton via steamboat around 1880.
The Old Jail of Chouteau County
The "Old Jail" of Fort Benton, Montana was built in 1881. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places and was described in one document as the oldest county jail in Montana. The Sheriff in office at the time it was built was Sheriff John Jerome Healy (b.d 1834 - 1908), one document states "he was neither good nor bad, but a little of both". It cost $15,000 to build, because of this Sheriff John Healy lost his next election. Voters felt the jail was too luxurious to house prisoners. The jail housed a few Vigilante-day offenders, notorious outlaws, moonshine runners, and people's involuntary stay linked to the misdeeds and misery that are the reason for jails.
One notable notorious outlaw who had a stay was Harvey Logan (AKA Curry) "Kid Curry" and his brother Lonny Logan (AKA Curry) for the murder of Powell "Pike" Lundasky. Landasky confronted Curry believing him involved with his daughter but was later found out it was his younger brother Lonny. The brothers who were members of the BlackJack Ketcham and Wild Bunch Gangs were released while waiting for trial and left town.
One notable notorious outlaw who had a stay was Harvey Logan (AKA Curry) "Kid Curry" and his brother Lonny Logan (AKA Curry) for the murder of Powell "Pike" Lundasky. Landasky confronted Curry believing him involved with his daughter but was later found out it was his younger brother Lonny. The brothers who were members of the BlackJack Ketcham and Wild Bunch Gangs were released while waiting for trial and left town.
The Old Jail did have other uses: There was a women's cell upstairs, that was little-used and would provide emergency shelter for people in need. The children of the community would use the hallway next to the dispatch office to change ice skates and warm up after skating at the nearby outdoor rink. The last Sheriff to hold office in the Old Jail was Sheriff Paul Williams, Williams was the driving force behind the construction of the new jail. Sheriff Paul Williams was the Sheriff of Chouteau County for 17 years, being appointed by Sheriff John Saksa in 1978.
The 150-year-old jail was demolished in 1986.
The 150-year-old jail was demolished in 1986.
Today's Sheriff's Office facility was built in 1986. This modern, up-to-date facility houses the Sheriff, Undersheriff, and the deputies. The facility also houses the Detention facility, and the 911 Public Safety Answering Point (PSAP). Chouteau County Sheriff's Office covers the towns of Big Sandy, Carter, Fort Benton, Geraldine, Highwood, Loma, Square Butte, and all rural areas within Chouteau County.